# The Nobel Prize for Literature

Are the citations written for winners of the Nobel Prize for Literature
becoming more and more incomprehensible?

The Swedish Academy started out more or less on the right track with an
award to Sully Prudhomme “in special recognition of his poetic
composition, which gives evidence of lofty idealism, artistic perfection
and a rare combination of the qualities of both heart and intellect.” A
little ornate perhaps, but this _is_ the Nobel Prize–“because he wrote a
bitchin’ book” wouldn’t cut it, to be sure.

In 1923 W.B. Yeats got the prize “for his always inspired poetry, which
in a highly artistic form gives expression to the spirit of a whole
nation.” By this time the citations had grown more grand, but they’re
still very much comprehensible. And there are still straight-forward
citations too: Sigrid Undset won in 1928 “principally for her powerful
descriptions of Northern life during the Middle Ages”; Pearl Buck won in
1938 “for her rich and truly epic descriptions of peasant life in China
and for her biographical masterpieces.”

By 1960 the citation’s sentence structure has increased significantly in
complexity: in that year Saint-John Perse won for “the soaring flight
and the evocative imagery of his poetry which in a visionary fashion
reflects the conditions of our time.” Easy enough to follow, I suppose,
but I can’t imagine the mostly unnecessary “in a visionary fashion”
popping up in such a fashion during the prize’s first few decades. I
wonder, too, if battles were fought over the inclusion of “soaring
flight.” It’s a little … poetic, don’t you think?

Eugenio Montale’s 1975 citation reads: “for his distinctive poetry
which, with great artistic sensitivity, has interpreted human values
under the sign of an outlook on life with no illusions.” The Academy’s
grip on the tendrils on meaning is slipping. To what does the “with no
illusions” belong? Does Montale _interpret_ “with no illusions,” or does
he use his _illusion-free outlook on life_ to “interpret human values”
(whatever _that_ means)? And “under the sign of”? The “with great
artistic sensitivity” is surely meaningless and serves only to futher
clog up what was already a pretty far-gone sentence.

The citation of 1983 (for Sir William Golding) has this form: “for his
novels which, with the A of B and the C of D, illuminate the human
condition in the world of today.” Now this citation has a fairly
straight-forward structure: if A had been, say, “clarity”, B had been
“Dr. Seuss”, C had been “charm” and D had been “A.A. Milne,” we would
have had a real citation on our hands. But of course the Academy would
fuck it up (again). The actual citation reads: “for his novels which,
with the perspicuity of realistic narrative art and the diversity and
universality of myth, illuminate the human condition in the world of
today.” Sigh. Is “realistic narrative art” really famed for its
_perspicuity_?? I’m not even sure if the citation is in the “A of B” and
“C of D” form. Whoever can tell? It’s a mess.

Things haven’t improved much. In 1998 the prize was won by Jose Saramago
“who with parables sustained by imagination, compassion and irony
continually enables us once again to apprehend an elusory reality.” I’m
particularly taken by the “continually enables us once again.” Why would
“enables us” not do? When we were “enabled” for the first time?

And in 2001, V.S. Naipaul received the prize for “having united
perceptive narrative and incorruptible scrutiny in works that compel us
to see the presence of suppressed histories.” Now I know what it means
for a police officer, say, to be “incorruptible.” But what does it mean
here? What author demonstrates _corruptible_ scrutiny? I can’t see any
justification for the “the presence,” either.

Are the citations the result of bad translations? Do they actually make
sense? Is it not worrisome that the citations for medicine (“for his
discovery of Prions–a new biological principle of infection”; “for their
discoveries of key regulators of the cell cycle”) make markedly more
sense than those for literature?

[The [official site](http://www.nobel.se/literature/laureates/) of the
Nobel Prize for Literature has the citations on separate pages; another,
far uglier site has them [on the same
page](http://almaz.com/nobel/literature/literature.html).]
