# Historia Calamitatum

By Peter Abelard.

I came at length to Paris, where
above all in those days the art of dialectics was most
flourishing, and there did I meet William of Champeaux, my
teacher, a man most distinguished in his science both by his
renown and by his true merit. With him I remained for some time,
at first indeed well liked of him; but later I brought him great
grief, because I undertook to refute certain of his opinions, not
infrequently attacking him in disputation, and now and then in
these debates I was adjudged victor. Now this, to those among my
fellow students who were ranked foremost, seemed all the more
insufferable because of my youth and the brief duration of my
studies.

— *Chapter II*

---

Out of this sprang the beginning of
my misfortunes, which have followed me even to the present day;
the more widely my fame was spread abroad, the more bitter was
the envy that was kindled against me.

— *Chapter II*

---

No long time thereafter I was smitten
with a grievous illness, brought upon me by my immoderate zeal
for study.

— *Chapter II*

---

Thus it came about that my teaching
won such strength and authority that even those who before had
clung most vehemently to my former master, and most bitterly
attacked my doctrines, now flocked to my school. The very man who
had succeeded to my master's chair in the Paris school offered me
his post, in order that he might put himself under my tutelage
along with all the rest, and this in the very place where of old
his master and mine had reigned. And when, in so short a time, my
master saw me directing the study of dialectics there, it is not
easy to find words to tell with what envy he was consumed or with
what pain he was tormented.

— *Chapter II*

---

The boast of Ajax, though I speak it more temperately, I
still am bold enough to make:

> "if fain you would learn now\
> How victory crowned the battle, by him was\
> I never vanquished."
>
> -- Ovid, "Metamorphoses," XIII, 89.

But even were I to be silent, the fact proclaims itself, and
its outcome reveals the truth regarding it.

— *Chapter II*

---

I sought out, therefore, this same
venerable man, whose fame, in truth, was more the result of long
established custom than of the potency of his own talent or
intellect. If any one came to him impelled by doubt on any
subject, he went away more doubtful still. He was wonderful,
indeed, in the eyes of these who only listened to him, but those
who asked him questions perforce held him as nought. He had a
miraculous flow of words, but they were contemptible in meaning
and quite void of reason. When he kindled a fire, he filled his
house with smoke and illumined it not at all. He was a tree which
seemed noble to those who gazed upon its leaves from afar, but to
those who came nearer and examined it more closely was revealed
its barrenness.

— *Chapter III*

---

... one day, after the exposition of
certain texts, we scholars were jesting among ourselves, and one
of them, seeking to draw me out, asked me what I thought of the
lectures on the Books of Scripture. I, who had as yet studied
only the sciences, replied that following such lectures seemed to
me most useful in so far as the salvation of the soul was
concerned, but that it appeared quite extraordinary to me that
educated persons should not be able to understand the sacred
books simply by studying them themselves, together with the
glosses thereon, and without the aid of any teacher. Most of
those who were present mocked at me, and asked whether I myself
could do as I had said, or whether I would dare to undertake it.
I answered that if they wished, I was ready to try it. Forthwith
they cried out and jeered all the more. "Well and good," said
they; "we agree to the test. Pick out and give us an exposition
of some doubtful passage in the Scriptures, I so that we can put
this boast of yours to the proof." And they all chose that most
obscure prophecy of Ezekiel.

— *Chapter III*

---

I accepted the challenge, and
invited them to attend a lecture on the very next day. Whereupon
they undertook to give me good advice, saying that I should by no
means make undue haste in so important a matter, but that I ought
to devote a much longer space to working out my exposition and
offsetting my inexperience by diligent toil. To this I replied
indignantly that it was my wont to win success, not by routine,
but by ability. I added that I would abandon the test altogether
unless they would agree not to put off their attendance at my
lecture. In truth at this first lecture of mine only a few were
present, for it seemed quite absurd to all of them that I,
hitherto so inexperienced in discussing the Scriptures, should
attempt the thing so hastily. However, this lecture gave such
satisfaction to all those who heard it that they spread its
praises abroad with notable enthusiasm, and thus compelled me to
continue my interpretation of the sacred text. When word of this
was bruited about, those who had stayed away from the first
lecture came eagerly, some to the second and more to the third,
and all of them were eager to write down the glosses which I had
begun on the first day, so as to have them from the very
beginning.

— *Chapter III*

---

Chiefly at their suggestion, as it
afterwards transpired, yonder venerable coward had the impudence
to forbid me to carry on any further in his school the work of
preparing glosses which I had thus begun. The pretext he alleged
was that if by chance in the course of this work I should write
anything containing blunders--as was likely enough in view of my
lack of training--the thing might be imputed to him. When this
came to the ears of his scholars, they were filled with
indignation at so undisguised a manifestation of spite, the like
of which had never been directed against any one before. The more
obvious this rancour became, the more it redounded to my honour,
and his persecution did nought save to make me more
famous.

— *Chapter IV*

---

At the very outset of my work there, I
set about completing the glosses on Ezekiel which I had begun at
Laon. These proved so satisfactory to all who read them that they
came to believe me no less adept in lecturing on theology than I
had proved myself to be in the field of philosophy.

— *Chapter V*

---

Thus my school was notably increased
in size by reason of my lectures on subjects of both these kinds,
and the amount of financial profit as well as glory which it
brought me cannot be concealed from you, for the matter talked
of. But prosperity always puffs up the foolish and worldly
comfort enervates the soul, rendering it an easy prey to carnal
temptations. Thus I who by this time had come to regard myself as
the only philosopher remaining in the whole world, and had ceased
to fear any further disturbance of my peace, began to loosen the
rein on my desires ...

— *Chapter V*

---

Thus did it come to pass that while I
was utterly absorbed in pride and sensuality, divine grace, the
cure for both diseases, was forced upon me, even though I,
forsooth would fain have shunned it. First was I punished for my
sensuality, and then for my pride. For my sensuality I lost those
things whereby I practiced it; for my pride, engendered in me by
my knowledge of letters and it is even as the Apostle said:
"Knowledge puffeth itself up" (I Cor. viii. 1) -- I knew the
humiliation of seeing burned the very book in which I most
gloried.

— *Chapter V*

---

Now there dwelt in that same city of
Paris a certain young girl named Heloise, the niece of a canon
who was called Fulbert. Her uncle's love for her was equalled
only by his desire that she should have the best education which
he could possibly procure for her. Of no mean beauty, she stood
out above all by reason of her abundant knowledge of letters. Now
this virtue is rare among women, and for that very reason it
doubly graced the maiden, and made her the most worthy of renown
in the entire kingdom. It was this young girl whom I, after
carefully considering all those qualities which are wont to
attract lovers, determined to unite with myself in the bonds of
love, and indeed the thing seemed to me very easy to be done. So
distinguished was my name, and I possessed such advantages of
youth and comeliness, that no matter what woman I might favour
with my love, I dreaded rejection of none.

— *Chapter VI*

---

... we might be able to write more
boldly than we could speak, and thus at all times could we live
in joyous intimacy.

— *Chapter VI*

---

Thus, utterly aflame with my passion
for this maiden, I sought to discover means whereby I might have
daily and familiar speech with her, thereby the more easily to
win her consent. For this purpose I persuaded the girl's uncle,
with the aid of some of his friends to take me into his
household--for he dwelt hard by my school--in return for the
payment of a small sum. My pretext for this was that the care of
my own household was a serious handicap to my studies, and
likewise burdened me with an expense far greater than I could
afford. Now he was a man keen in avarice and likewise he was most
desirous for his niece that her study of letters should ever go
forward, so, for these two reasons I easily won his consent to
the fulfillment of my wish, for he was fairly agape for my money,
and at the same time believed that his niece would vastly benefit
by my teaching. More even than this, by his own earnest
entreaties he fell in with my desires beyond anything I had dared
to hope, opening the way for my love; for he entrusted her wholly
to my guidance, begging me to give her instruction whensoever I
might be free from the duties of my school, no matter whether by
day or by night, and to punish her sternly if ever I should find
her negligent of her tasks.

— *Chapter VI*

---

In all this the man's simplicity was
nothing short of astounding to me; I should not have been more
smitten with wonder if he had entrusted a tender lamb to the care
of a ravenous wolf. When he had thus given her into my charge,
not alone to be taught but even to be disciplined, what had he
done save to give free scope to my desires, and to offer me every
opportunity, even if I had not sought it, to bend her to my will
with threats and blows if I failed to do so with
caresses?

— *Chapter VI*

---

We were united first in the dwelling
that sheltered our love, and then in the hearts that burned with
it. Under the pretext of study we spent our hours in the
happiness of love, and learning held out to us the secret
opportunities that our passion craved. Our speech was more of
love than of the books which lay open before us; our kisses far
outnumbered our reasoned words. Our hands sought less the book
than each other's bosoms -- love drew our eyes together far more
than the lesson drew them to the pages of our text.

— *Chapter VI*

---

In order that there might be no
suspicion, there were, indeed, sometimes blows, but love gave
them, not anger; they were the marks, not of wrath, but of a
tenderness surpassing the most fragrant balm in
sweetness.

— *Chapter VI*

---

No degree in love's progress was left
untried by our passion, and if love itself could imagine any
wonder as yet unknown, we discovered it. And our inexperience of
such delights made us all the more ardent in our pursuit of them,
so that our thirst for one another was still unquenched.

— *Chapter VI*

---

In measure as this passionate rapture
absorbed me more and more, I devoted ever less time to philosophy
and to the work of the school. Indeed it became loathsome to me
to go to the school or to linger there; the labour, moreover, was
very burdensome, since my nights were vigils of love and my days
of study. My lecturing became utterly careless and lukewarm; I
did nothing because of inspiration, but everything merely as a
matter of habit. I had become nothing more than a reciter of my
former discoveries, and though I still wrote poems, they dealt
with love, not with the secrets of philosophy. Of these songs you
yourself well know how some have become widely known and have
been sung in many lands, chiefly, methinks, by those who
delighted in the things of this world. As for the sorrow, the
groans, the lamentations of my students when they perceived the
preoccupation, nay, rather the chaos, of my mind, it is hard even
to imagine them.

— *Chapter VI*

---

Oh, how great was the uncle's grief
when he learned the truth, and how bitter was the sorrow of the
lovers when we were forced to part! With what shame was I
overwhelmed, with what contrition smitten because of the blow
which had fallen on her I loved, and what a tempest of misery
burst over her by reason of my disgrace! Each grieved most, not
for himself, but for the other. Each sought to allay, not his own
sufferings, but those of the one he loved. The very sundering of
our bodies served but to link our souls closer together; the
plentitude of the love which was denied to us inflamed us more
than ever. Once the first wildness of shame had passed, it left
us more shameless than before, and as shame died within us the
cause of it seemed to us ever more desirable.

— *Chapter VI*

---

She asked how she could ever glory
in me if she should make me thus inglorious, and should shame
herself along with me. What penalties, she said, would the world
rightly demand of her if she should rob it of so shining a light!
What curses would follow such a loss to the Church, what tears
among the philosophers would result from such a marriage! How
unfitting, how lamentable it would be for me, whom nature had
made for the whole world, to devote myself to one woman solely,
and to subject myself to such humiliation! She vehemently
rejected this marriage, which she felt would be in every way
ignominious and burdensome to me.

— *Chapter VII*

---

... in the same work, St. Jerome
tells how Cicero, asked by Hircius after his divorce of Terentia
whether he would marry the sister of Hircius, replied that he
would do no such thing, saying that he could not devote himself
to a wife and to philosophy at the same time. Cicero does not,
indeed, precisely speak of "devoting himself," but he does add
that he did not wish to undertake anything which might rival his
study of philosophy in its demands upon him.

— *Chapter VII*

---

What possible concord could there be
between scholars and domestics, between authors and cradles,
between books or tablets and distaffs, between the stylus or the
pen and the spindle? What man, intent on his religious or
philosophical meditations, can possibly endure the whining of
children, the lullabies of the nurse seeking to quiet them, or
the noisy confusion of family life? Who can endure the continual
untidiness of children? The rich, you may reply, can do this,
because they have palaces or houses containing many rooms, and
because their wealth takes no thought of expense and protects
them from daily worries. But to this the answer is that the
condition of philosophers is by no means that of the wealthy, nor
can those whose minds are occupied with riches and worldly cares
find time for religious or philosophical study. For this reason
the renowned philosophers of old utterly despised the world,
fleeing from its perils rather than reluctantly giving them up,
and denied themselves all its delights in order that they might
repose in the embraces of philosophy alone. One of them, and the
greatest of all, Seneca, in his advice to Lucilius, says
philosophy is not a thing to be studied only in hours of leisure;
we must give up everything else to devote ourselves to it, for no
amount of time is really sufficient hereto (Epist. 73)

— *Chapter VII*

---

Her final argument was that it would
be dangerous for me to take her back to Paris, and that it would
be far sweeter for her to be called my mistress than to be known
as my wife; nay, too, that this would be more honourable for me
as well. In such case, she said, love alone would hold me to her,
and the strength of the marriage chain would not constrain us.
Even if we should by chance be parted from time to time, the joy
of our meetings would be all the sweeter by reason of its
rarity.

— *Chapter VII*

---

... one night while I all
unsuspecting was asleep in a secret room in my lodgings, they
[Heloise's uncle and his kinsmen] broke in with the help of one
of my servants whom they had bribed. There they had vengeance on
me with a most cruel and most shameful punishment, such as
astounded the whole world; for they cut off those parts of my
body with which I had done that which was the cause of their
sorrow. This done, straightway they fled, but two of them were
captured and suffered the loss of their eyes and their genital
organs. One of these two was the aforesaid servant, who even
while he was still in my service, had been led by his avarice to
betray me.

— *Chapter VII*

---

... scarcely had I recovered from
my wound when clerics sought me in great numbers, endlessly
beseeching both my abbot and me myself that now, since I was done
with learning for the sake of pain or renown, I should turn to it
for the sole love of God.

— *Chapter VIII*

---

The abbey, however, to which I had
betaken myself was utterly worldly and in its life quite
scandalous. The abbot himself was as far below his fellows in his
way of living and in the foulness of his reputation as he was
above them in priestly rank. This intolerable state of things I
often and vehemently denounced, sometimes in private talk and
sometimes publicly, but the only result was that I made myself
detested of them all. They gladly laid hold of the daily
eagerness of my students to hear me as an excuse whereby they
might be rid of me; and finally, at the insistent urging of the
students themselves, and with the hearty consent of the abbot and
the rest of the brotherhood, I departed thence to a certain hut,
there to teach in my wonted way. To this place such a throng of
students flocked that the neighbourhood could not afford shelter
for them, nor the earth sufficient sustenance.

— *Chapter VIII*

---

Since apparently the Lord had gifted
me with no less persuasiveness in expounding the Scriptures than
in lecturing on secular subjects, the number of my students in
these two courses began to increase greatly, and the attendance
at all the other schools was correspondingly diminished. Thus I
aroused the envy and hatred of the other teachers.

— *Chapter VIII*

---

Now, a great many people saw and read
this tract, and it became exceedingly popular, its clearness
appealing particularly to all who sought information on this
subject. And since the questions involved are generally
considered the most difficult of all, their complexity is taken
as the measure of the subtlety of him who succeeds in answering
them.

— *Chapter IX*

---

These three, then, took my book and
pawed it over and examined it minutely, but could find nothing
therein which they dared to use as the basis for a public
accusation against me. Accordingly they put off the condemnation
of the book until the close of the council, despite their
eagerness to bring it about. For my part, every day before the
council convened I publicly discussed the Catholic faith in the
light of what I had written, and all who heard me were
enthusiastic in their approval alike of the frankness and the
logic of my words. When the public and the clergy had thus
learned something of the real character of my teaching, they
began to say to one another: "Behold, now he speaks openly, and
no one brings any charge against him. And this council, summoned,
as we have heard, chiefly to take action upon his case is drawing
toward its end. Did the judges realize that the error might be
theirs rather than his?"

— *Chapter IX*

---

As a result of all this, my rivals
grew more angry day by day. On one occasion Alberic, accompanied
by some of his students, came to me for the purpose of
intimidating me, and, after a few bland words, said that he was
amazed at something he had found in my book, to the effect that,
although God had begotten God, I denied that God had begotten
Himself, since there was only one God. I answered unhesitatingly:
"I can give you an explanation of this if you wish it." "Nay," he
replied, "I care nothing for human explanation or reasoning in
such matters, but only for the words of authority." "Very well, I
said; "turn the pages of my book and you will find the authority
likewise." The book was at hand, for he had brought it with him.
I turned to the passage I had in mind, which he had either not
discovered or else passed over as containing nothing injurious to
me. And it was God's will that I quickly found what I sought.
This was the following sentence, under the heading "Augustine, On
the Trinity, Book I": "Whosoever believes that it is within the
power of God to beget Himself is sorely in error; this power is
not in God, neither is it in any created thing, spiritual or
corporeal. For there is nothing that can give birth to
itself."

— *Chapter IX*

---

When those of his followers who were
present heard this, they were amazed and much embarrassed. He
himself, in order to keep his countenance, said: "Certainly, I
understand all that." Then I added: "What I have to say further
on this subject is by no means new, but apparently it has nothing
to do with the case at issue, since you have asked for the word
of authority only, and not for explanations. If, however, you
care to consider logical explanations, I am prepared to
demonstrate that, according to Augustine's statement, you have
yourself fallen into a heresy in believing that a father can
possibly be his own son." When Alberic heard this he was almost
beside himself with rage, and straightway resorted to threats,
asserting that neither my explanations nor my citations of
authority would avail me aught in this case. With this he left
me.

— *Chapter IX*

---

Straightaway upon my summons I went to
the council, and there, without further examination or debate,
did they compel me with my own hand to cast that memorable book
of mine into the flames. Although my enemies appeared to have
nothing to say while the book was burning, one of them muttered
something about having seen it written therein that God the
Father was alone omnipotent. This reached the ears of the legate,
who replied in astonishment that he could not believe that even a
child would make so absurd a blunder.

— *Chapter X*

---

When, however, I fain would have
arisen to profess and set forth my faith, in order that I might
express in my own words that which was in my heart, my enemies
declared that it was not needful for me to do more than recite
the Athanasian Symbol, a thing which any boy might do as well as
I. And lest I should allege ignorance, pretending that I did not
know the words by heart, they had a copy of it set before me to
read.

— *Chapter X*

---

Comparing these new sufferings of my
soul with those I had formerly endured in my body, it seemed that
I was in very truth the most miserable among men. Indeed that
earlier betrayal had become a little thing in comparison with
this later evil, and I lamented the hurt to my fair name far more
than the one to my body. The latter, indeed, I had brought upon
myself through my own wrongdoing, but this other violence had
come upon me solely by reason of the honesty of my purpose and my
love of our faith, which had compelled me to write that which I
believed.

— *Chapter X*

---

After a few months had passed, chance gave them an
opportunity by which they sought to destroy me. It happened
that one day, in the course of my reading, I came upon a
certain passage of Bede, in his commentary on the Acts of the
Apostles, wherein he asserts that Dionysius the Areopagite was
the bishop, not of Athens, but of Corinth. Now, this was
directly counter to the belief of the monks, who were wont to
boast that their Dionysius, or Denis, was not only the
Areopagite but was likewise proved by his acts to have been the
Bishop of Athens. Having thus found this testimony of Bede's in
contradiction of our own tradition, I showed it somewhat
jestingly to sundry of the monks who chanced to be near.
Wrathfully they declared that Bede was no better than a liar,
and that they had a far more trustworthy authority in the
person of Hilduin, a former abbot of theirs, who had travelled
for a long time throughout Greece for the purpose of
investigating this very question. He, they insisted, had by his
writings removed all possible doubt on the subject, and had
securely established the truth of the traditional belief.

One of the monks went so far as to ask me brazenly which of
the two, Bede or Hilduin, I considered the better authority on
this point. I replied that the authority of Bede, whose
writings are held in high esteem by the whole Latin Church,
appeared to me the better. Thereupon in a great rage they began
to cry out that at last I had openly proved the hatred I had
always felt for our monastery, and that I was seeking to
disgrace it in the eyes of the whole kingdom, robbing it of the
honour in which it had particularly gloried, by thus denying
that the Areopagite was their patron saint. To this I answered
that I had never denied the fact, and that I did not much care
whether their patron was the Areopagite or some one else,
provided only he had received his crown from God.

— *Chapter X*

---

No sooner had scholars learned of my
retreat than they began to flock thither from all sides, leaving
their towns and castles to dwell in the wilderness. In place of
their spacious houses they built themselves huts; instead of
dainty fare they lived on the herbs of the field and coarse
bread; their soft beds they exchanged for heaps of straw and
rushes, and their tables were piles of turf. in very truth you
may well believe that they were like those philosophers of old of
whom Jerome tells us in his second book against
Jovinianus.

— *Chapter XI*

---

And as their number grew ever
greater, the hardships which they gladly endured for the sake of
my teaching seemed to my rivals to reflect new glory on me, and
to cast new shame on themselves.

— *Chapter XI*

---

The thing which at that time chiefly
led me to undertake the direction of a school was my intolerable
poverty, for I had not strength enough to dig, and shame kept me
from begging. And so, resorting once more to the art with which I
was so familiar, I was compelled to substitute the service of the
tongue for the labour of my hands. The students willingly
provided me with whatsoever I needed in the way of food and
clothing, and likewise took charge of the cultivation of the
fields and paid for the erection of buildings, in order that
material cares might not keep me from my studies. Since my
oratory was no longer large enough to hold even a small part of
their number, they found it necessary to increase its size, and
in so doing they greatly improved it, building it of stone and
wood. Although this oratory had been founded in honour of the
Holy Trinity, and afterwards dedicated thereto, I now named it
the Paraclete, mindful of how I had come there a fugitive and in
despair, and had breathed into my soul something of the miracle
of divine consolation.

— *Chapter XI*

---

Many of those who heard of this were
greatly astonished, and some violently assailed my action,
declaring that it was not permissible to dedicate a church
exclusively to the Holy Spirit rather than to God the Father.
They held, according to an ancient tradition, that 'it must be
dedicated either to the Son alone or else to the entire
Trinity.

— *Chapter XI*

---

It was not, however, with the thought
of dedicating my oratory to one Person that I first called it the
Paraclete, but for the reason I have already told, that in this
spot I found consolation. None the less, even if I had done it
for the reason attributed to me, the departure from the usual
custom would have been in no way illogical.

— *Chapter XI*

---

And so I dwelt in this place, my
body indeed hidden away, but my fame spreading throughout the
whole world, till its echo reverberated mightily--echo, that
fancy of the poet's, which has so great a voice, and nought
beside.

— *Chapter XII*

---

Stunned by this fear like one smitten with a thunderbolt ...

— *Chapter XII*

---

The land was barbarous and its
speech was unknown to me; as for the monks, their vile and
untameable way of life was notorious almost everywhere. The
people of the region, too, were uncivilized and lawless. Thus,
like one who in terror of the sword that threatens him dashes
headlong over a precipice, and to shun one death for a moment
rushes to another, I knowingly sought this new danger in order to
escape from the former one.

— *Chapter XIII*

---

No one, methinks, could fail to
understand how persistently that undisciplined body of monks, the
direction of which I had thus undertaken, tortured my heart day
and night, or how constantly I was compelled to think of the
danger alike to my body and to my soul. I held it for certain
that if I should try to force them to live according to the
principles they had themselves professed, I should not
survive.

— *Chapter XIII*

---

True it is that the weakness of
womankind makes their needs and sufferings appeal strongly to
people's feelings, as likewise it makes their virtue all the more
pleasing to God and man.

— *Chapter XIII*

---

And God granted such favour in the
eyes of all to her who was now my sister, and who was in
authority over the rest, that the bishops loved her as a
daughter, the abbots as a sister, and the laity as a mother. All
alike marvelled at her religious zeal, her good judgment and the
sweetness of her incomparable patience in all things. The less
often she allowed herself to be seen, shutting herself up in her
cell to devote herself to sacred meditations and prayers, the
more eagerly did those who dwelt without demand her presence and
the spiritual guidance of her words.

— *Chapter XIII*

---

The more power such women exercise
over men, the more easily can they lead them into iniquitous
desires, and in this way can lay a very heavy yoke upon their
shoulders.

— *Chapter XIII*
