The Grey Album is actually pretty damn good, although I’m sure it’s naughtiness is part of its charm. However, the existence of one or more pieces of good-though-illegal art is not, in itself, an argument for invalidating the laws that made them illegal in the first place. The greytuesday site argues that the Grey Album should be legal. And perhaps it should. But what should not? What is sampling? What is music? If I lay a few tom toms over the White Album is that sampling? Is adding background music to a recorded speech sampling? I can’t support a movement to reform music law before knowing what the desired reforms actually are: and the greytuesday site has precious little to say about this.